machine:Machine checks passed: 6/6. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met. The claimant created an original public GitHub repo at https://github.com/armstrongsam25/runx-demo with a substantive walkthrough covering what runx is, why it matters (governed authority, sealed receipts, authority narrowing), a quick start with CLI commands, skill anatomy (SKILL.md, X.yaml, fixtures), a hello-world example, the receipt format with a real JSON example, and MCP serving instructions. The README links to both https://runx.ai and https://github.com/runxhq/runx. The evidence_json contains all six required observation keys (claim_type, public_url, runx_link_found, summary, audience, why_allowed) with 7 items total. The report names what was posted, where it lives, and why it is authentic support. The repo is the claimant's own, the URL is live (HTTP 200), and all three artifacts were fetched successfully. No dealbreakers. Score: 4/5, above the floor of 3.

human review:Human review checked the reachable public action, evidence packet, and report against the goodwill bounty bar; no dead links, spam-only action, screenshot-only proof, or secret leakage found.

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:The skill built does not match the bounty specification. The bounty requires typed inputs `thread` (support thread turns) and `sla_policy`, with typed outputs `signals{sentiment, sla_breach, churn_risk}` and `escalation{needed, priority, context}`. The claimant built a queue-clustering tool: X.yaml defines `queue` as the input, the harness cases pass ticket arrays, and the logic uses Jaccard similarity on ticket subjects with union-find clustering to detect volume/severity/stale signals. That is a different skill. The typed input/output contract is wrong at the root. Specific failures by acceptance bullet: 1. Wrong typed inputs and outputs. X.yaml uses `queue`, `context`, `escalation_policy` not `thread` and `sla_policy`. The output schema is `runx.support.firewatch.v1` with `ticket_ids`, `max_severity`, `oldest_age` not `signals{sentiment, sla_breach, churn_risk}` and `escalation{needed, priority, context}`. Fix: rebuild the skill to accept `thread` (turns array) and `sla_policy` (first_response_hours, resolution_hours) and emit the specified signal and escalation objects. 2. Wrong harness second case. The bounty requires one sealed case where a breached or strongly negative thread emits `escalation.needed: true`, and one refused/no-escalation case where a healthy thread emits no escalation. The second case is `stop_empty_queue` (exit 64 on empty queue), not a healthy-thread all-clear. Fix: replace the second case with a healthy thread input that produces `escalation.needed: false`. 3. evidence_json.dogfood missing required fields. The bounty requires `{ package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, harness_cases }`. The submitted dogfood block contains only `{ input, output, receipt_id }`. Missing: `package`, `command`, `verify_verdict`, `harness_cases` (each case name with sealed/refused status). Fix: re-run the dogfood step, capture the full command, run `runx verify --receipt <receipt.json> --json`, and record all required fields. 4. evidence_json.observations does not include the runx CLI version string. The acceptance bullet requires the exact `runx --version` output (`runx-cli 0.6.16`) to appear inside `observations`. It appears only in `runx_cli_version` at the top level. Fix: add an observation item with the exact version output string. 5. Version consistency. Artifact files (x_yaml, skill_md, evidence_json) are pinned to commit `4f22134f780105252f9d4da7b5931de666521b88` but `verification_json.source_repo.commit_sha` is `29b4802ee40b207c027ad06681d54615a08a45b6`. These must all reference the same commit. Fix: align all artifacts to a single commit. 6. evidence_json.observations do not cover the full required list: publisher owner, package name, version, registry ref, public_url, pr_url, source_url, raw x_yaml and skill_md URLs, publish method, install command, hosted harness status, dogfood command, runx verify verdict, and new-user walkthrough are absent from observations. Fix: add observations covering each of these items. The core issue is the wrong skill. Redelivery requires rebuilding to the `thread` + `sla_policy` specification before the other gaps matter. Rubric blockers: auto_review_verdict: The skill built does not match the bounty specification. The bounty requires typed inputs `thread` (support thread turns) and `sla_policy`, with typed outputs `signals{sentiment, sla_breach, churn_risk}` and `escalation{needed, priority, context}`. The claimant built a queue-c...

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met by inspectable evidence. CLI version: runx-cli 0.6.16 confirmed in evidence_json and verification_json, satisfying the 0.6.14 floor. GitHub star: Machine verifier github.repo_starred_by confirmed @armstrongsam25 stars runxhq/runx (starred 2026-07-01). Package name and publish: Exact name sbom-maker, published as armstrongsam25/sbom-maker@sha-253beda84911. public_url resolves live and shows the correct owner. No secrets in artifacts. PR: https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/246 is live. x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from the worker's repo at the pinned commit, both return HTTP 200 with correct content. Version consistency: All artifacts reference the same package version sha-253beda84911. There is a commit hash discrepancy in the evidence_json summary text (a65bc2ab) vs the actual artifact URLs (2c9000a0), but all bound artifacts resolve correctly at 2c9000a0 and the package version is consistent throughout. Not a dealbreaker. Harness: Machine verifier runx.skill_harness confirmed 2 cases, 2 receipts, hosted harness passed. X.yaml shows sbom-maker-valid-npm-lockfile (sealed) and sbom-maker-malformed-lockfile (refused), covering the required sealed and refused case pair. Dogfood and verify: evidence_json.dogfood contains package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict (valid), and harness_cases with names and statuses. verification_json confirms signature, digest, and content address all valid. Receipt is the post-publish dogfood run, not a harness fixture seal. Typed inputs and outputs: X.yaml runners section declares lockfile (json, required) and lockfile_type (string, required) as inputs; sbom (object), components (array), license_summary (object), license_risks (array) as outputs. Read-only, offline: SKILL.md explicitly states no network lookups, all data derived from supplied lockfile. Components grounded: Dogfood output shows 2 components with name, version, license, and evidence locations per component. Documentation coverage: Report and evidence_json (16 observations) cover all required fields including CLI version, owner, package, version, registry ref, public_url, pr_url, source_url, publish method, install command, harness case names, hosted harness status, dogfood command, receipt_ref, verify verdict, and new-user install/run/verify steps. Real-world value: An offline CycloneDX SBOM generator from lockfiles with license risk flagging is a useful security tooling primitive for CI gates, pre-release checks, and license compliance. The skill is installable, harness-verified, and produces a sealed, verifiable receipt.

human review:PR #246 head is armstrongsam25/runx@54a4a848, while submitted source/raw artifacts are from armstrongsam25/runx-sbom-maker-skill@2c9000a; artifacts are not a single auditable claimant-authored revision.

machine:Verifier failed: 1 required check(s) failed.

runx_skill_harness: No hosted runx harness endpoint passed: Harness endpoint returned HTTP 404.; Hosted harness status is not_recorded, expected passed. Fix: Publish the skill through hosted runx and make sure its harness is green.

machine:Machine checks passed: 1/1. Review pending with human or llm.