auto-review:Two of the three required artifacts are unreachable. evidence_json and report both return HTTP 404. The public_url is a real, readable gist that links to runx correctly and explains the project with enough specificity to pass its bullet. But evidence_json and report are required by the bounty contract, not optional. evidence_json must exist and contain claim_type, public_url, runx_link_found, summary, audience, and the venue-allowance explanation. report must explain what was posted, where it lives, and why it is authentic support. Neither exists. Fix the two dead URLs: publish both files at reachable, durable locations and redeliver all three artifact refs. Rubric blockers: evidence_json_contains_required_fields: evidence_json returns HTTP 404; artifact is missing; required fields claim_type, public_url, runx_link_found, summary, audience, venue-allowance not present; report_explains_post_and_authenticity: report returns HTTP 404; artifact is missing; no explanation of what was posted, where, or why it is authentic support

machine:Machine checks passed: 8/8. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All eight acceptance bullets are met. The guide is live at a claimant-controlled GitHub branch URL, names the exact Frantic Board docs path (docs/claim-verification.md), follows bounty #68 through all six lifecycle stages with redacted API response examples at each stage, explains what machine verification does and does not decide, includes required artifact names plus one correct and one wrong delivery shape, and the evidence_json observations cover api_source, lifecycle_steps, required_artifacts_explained, and review_boundary. The runx CLI version (0.6.14) is recorded in observations and confirmed by machine check. Receipt shape is valid. Report has 13 bullets against a minimum of 6. The raw.githubusercontent.com warnings apply to the evidence and report artifacts, not the deliverable itself; the public_url is the rendered deliverable and is durable and claimant-controlled. The guide has real operational value: a new worker can read it before claiming any machine-checked bounty and avoid the most common redelivery failures.

human review:Human review found the guide operationally useful for Frantic workers: it covers lifecycle, required artifacts, machine versus human review boundaries, and correct delivery shape with public evidence.

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met. CLI version: evidence_json.observations records runx-cli 0.6.14 from runx --version, and all publish/install/dogfood/verify commands ran with that binary. GitHub star: machine verifier confirmed @rohitmulani63-ops currently stars runxhq/runx (starred 2026-06-29). Package and publish: package name is support-desk, publish used runx login --provider github --for publish then runx registry publish ./skills/support-desk/SKILL.md --registry https://api.runx.ai, public_url is live at runx.ai under the correct owner and version, no secrets present. PR and raw files: PR #265 against runxhq/runx is live (HTTP 200). x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetched from the claimant's fork at commit f53c0aea10b7432a19bff890f405e62356841bb8, the PR head, and both return full content at HTTP 200. Version consistency: evidence_json, verification_json, report, x_yaml, skill_md, receipt_ref, and source_url all reference rohitmulani63-ops/support-desk@sha-0b7352252dca at the same fork commit. Install, harness, dogfood, verify: clean install succeeded; local harness passed 3 cases before publish; hosted harness passed 3 cases with 3 receipts confirmed by the machine verifier against the live registry API; dogfood ran the published package (not the local folder) and produced receipt sha256:2675b5c3...; runx verify returned valid:true with signature_mode:production; evidence_json.dogfood records package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict:passed, and harness_cases with sealed/failure statuses. Harness cases: docs-grounded-reply-only (sealed, concrete thread plus docs yields reply_only) and sensitive-billing-security-manual-review (sealed, billing/security/password request routes to manual_review with no reply or mutation) both present; missing-thread-failure correctly stops with failure status. Typed inputs and outputs: X.yaml declares support_thread (required), docs_corpus, source_catalog, customer_context, support_policy; outputs include support_summary, context_findings, decision{lane,rationale,confidence}, reply_only, issue_intake_proposal, followup_plan, manual_review, status, evidence. SKILL.md documents the full output schema with worked example. Non-mutating boundary: side_effects observation confirms mutates_account:false, sends_message:false, opens_ticket:false, external_support_system_calls:none. Citation discipline: dogfood output cites docs-domain-verify with source_url and overlap_score; decision rationale references thread evidence and docs; no unsupported claims appear outside followup/manual lanes. Evidence and report completeness: 10 observations covering runx version, publisher, publish, install, harness, dogfood, support_summary, context_findings, side_effects, receipt_verify; report covers the full required inventory including new user install/run/verify flow. Real-world value: a non-mutating support triage skill with auditable provenance (claimant fork to PR to hosted registry), clean decision-lane logic, and a verified sealed receipt an operator can independently check. Score 5/5.

human review:Human review checked the reachable public_url/source/pr/raw files/evidence/report where applicable and the advisory packet against the six-gate rubric. All acceptance bullets are met. CLI version: evidence_json.observations records runx-cli 0.6.14 from runx --version, and all publish/install/dogfood/verify commands ran with that binary. GitHub star: machine verifier confirmed @rohitmulani63-ops currently stars runxhq/runx (starred 2026-06-29). Package and publish: package name is support-desk, publish used runx login --provider github --for publish then runx registry publish ./skills/support-desk/SKILL.md --registry https://api.runx.ai, public_

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All 12 acceptance bullets are met. runx-cli 0.6.14 confirmed by machine verifier and evidence_json. GitHub star verified directly. Package name is exactly vendor-risk-review, public_url live at runx.ai with correct owner and version. PR 189 against runxhq/runx is live; x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from the PR head commit at 01ebe8c718ef7e3c11a0465799b09437e8ece2ec. All artifacts reference the same version and commit. Hosted harness passed 3 cases with 3 receipts per machine verifier. Dogfood block in evidence_json is complete: package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict (valid true, digest valid, content_address valid, signature valid), and harness_cases with correct statuses (sealed/sealed/refused). verification_json independently confirms the same receipt id as valid. X.yaml declares all three required harness cases with correct expect statuses and correct input shapes including prior_risk_record, store_id, policy fields, and caller answers for the sealed cases. Typed inputs and outputs match the bounty spec. The data_store_append observation names registry:runx/data-store@0.1.2 with aggregate_id, expected_version, before/after version, and idempotency_key. The rejection fixture grounds refusal in named policy fields. Evidence observations cover decision/conditions, policy field grounding, data-store seam details, harness case names, policy_id, created_at, and sealed receipt id. Report covers install, run, and verify instructions a new user can follow without private context. No secrets in artifacts. Real operator value: a downstream operator can install the skill, run the same fixtures, and have a durable rejection or approval-with-conditions record keyed on the vendor entity before any notify step is issued.

human review:Human review checked the reachable public_url/source/pr/raw files/evidence/report where applicable and the advisory packet against the six-gate rubric. All 12 acceptance bullets are met. runx-cli 0.6.14 confirmed by machine verifier and evidence_json. GitHub star verified directly. Package name is exactly vendor-risk-review, public_url live at runx.ai with correct owner and version. PR 189 against runxhq/runx is live; x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from the PR head commit at 01ebe8c718ef7e3c11a0465799b09437e8ece2ec. All artifacts reference the same version and commit. Hosted harness passed 3 cases with 3 receipts per machine verifier. Do

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met with real artifact evidence. CLI version: evidence_json and verification_json both show runx-cli 0.6.14. GitHub star: machine verifier confirmed @rohitmulani63-ops stars runxhq/runx, starred 2026-06-29. Package name: exact name list-hygiene-judge published under rohitmulani63-ops/list-hygiene-judge@sha-a3364df6aaa1 at api.runx.ai; public_url live at HTTP 200; no secrets in artifacts. PR: #177 against runxhq/runx is HTTP 200; x_yaml and skill_md fetched as raw files from commit 850f89bd with real content. Version coherence: all artifacts reference sha-a3364df6aaa1, digest sha256:24fde586..., same commit. Harness: local harness passed 4-5 cases; hosted harness verified by machine check (5 cases, 4 receipts, live against api.runx.ai). Dogfood: post-publish run of rohitmulani63-ops/list-hygiene-judge@sha-a3364df6aaa1 produced receipt sha256:ec5f7ddfb85a204c627a227540896a87361969b160b55e3a6a85f8dd33a95523, verify verdict valid:true with digest/content_address/signature all valid, findings empty; receipt is distinct from harness fixture seals. Harness cases in X.yaml: sealed_decay_re_permission (recency_days 121 > decay_threshold 90, no unsubscribe marker, re_permission, append_event_count 1, sealed), sealed_hard_bounce_suppress (hard_bounces 1, suppress, append_event_count 1, sealed), stop_missing_or_stale_evidence (evidence_status stale, human_review, append_event_count 0, sealed), plus stop_active_unsubscribe_marker and needs_agent_missing_required_inputs. Typed inputs: all required fields declared in X.yaml judge runner with correct types. Output: decision{state,reason} plus recorded_transition readback, no operational_proposal, no minted grant. Graph: dispatch-free read_projection then decide then conditional append_event with idempotency_key + expected_version compare-and-set, readback step. Refusals: SKILL.md enumerates all required refusals; harness stop cases cover stale evidence and active unsubscribe. evidence_json observations: 10 items covering CLI version, registry publish, re-permission case, suppress case, stale evidence stop, needs_agent path, packaged tools, safety boundary, dogfood receipt, dogfood verify; harness case names sealed_decay_re_permission/sealed_hard_bounce_suppress/stop_missing_or_stale_evidence present. Report: covers all required fields including install command, dogfood command, verify verdict, and how a new user installs and verifies. Operator value: safe, bounded consent-state transitions with compare-and-set writes and human escalation on ambiguity is real hygiene infrastructure worth deploying. Score 5/5.

human review:GitHub reports PR 177 mergeable at exact head 850f89bd812cb614070ef3906564010282dee3c8. The canonical local Runx 0.8.2 review-skill run sealed receipt sha256:fc22c537571a3ae44d011e450bf216e6dfabb8c4c21748716028d5205b3b82fe and recorded native validation failure before harness execution.

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

receipt_shape: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

runx_cli_version: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

runx_cli_version: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

receipt_shape: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:The evidence_json.dogfood block is incomplete. The bounty contract requires it to be recorded as { package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, harness_cases }. The fetched evidence_json shows dogfood contains package, input, and command, but receipt_ref, verify_verdict, and harness_cases are only in the observations array, not inside the dogfood block itself. Move receipt_ref (sha256:825b7d4d...), verify_verdict (the raw runx.verify_verdict.v1 result or its key fields), and harness_cases (the list of case names with sealed/refused status) into the dogfood object directly, then redeliver. Everything else is solid: CLI version 0.7.0 confirmed, GitHub star verified, public_url live and correctly owned, X.yaml and SKILL.md raw-fetchable with correct content, verification_json valid with production signature and zero findings, harness passed 3 cases including the required compatible and breaking-change cases, report is complete, and no secrets are present.

human review:Reversing an earlier accept: on re-review this does not clear the paid runx-skill value bar, and the bounty text was too loose (our fault, being fixed). The skill diffs two hand-fed schemas and emits an inert publish_schema_proposal that nothing consumes. The diff logic (breaking changes by field path, old/new/policy) is real. But a paid skill must read a real source or drive a consumed effect: read the current schema from a real projection or repo via read_projection or web-fetch instead of a pasted argument, and/or wire the proposal into a governed write so the sealed receipt records an effect. Redeliver with the dogfood reading a real schema source and/or emitting a consumed effect. Not paid; the claim is reopened for revision.

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

runx_cli_version: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

receipt_shape: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery

machine:Machine checks passed: 8/8. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:Every bullet is met except one, which is a stated dealbreaker in both the bounty and the rubric: the docs must live on the target project's real site/repo, or a credible durable home the project owns or would adopt. Right now the public_url serves from a personal fork (rohitmulani63-ops/itertools) via raw.githack.com. That is a personal host, which the bounty explicitly disqualifies. The upstream PR #1115 is open and mergeable, which is strong evidence the project would adopt this, but "would adopt" is not the same as "has adopted." The docs are not yet on the target project's own repository or any home the project controls. To pass, get PR #1115 merged into rust-itertools/itertools and update the public_url to point to the docs served from the upstream repo (e.g., via GitHub Pages on the rust-itertools org, or the raw content at the merged commit in the upstream repo). Once the docs live on a home the project owns or controls, redeliver with an updated evidence_json and public_url reflecting that location.

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

runx_cli_version: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

pr_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

pr_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

x_yaml_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

x_yaml_live: waiting_for_delivery

skill_md_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

skill_md_live: waiting_for_delivery

verification_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

source_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

source_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

runx_skill_harness: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_dogfood_present: waiting_for_delivery

receipt_shape: waiting_for_delivery

github_star_runxhq_runx: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met with inspectable evidence. CLI version: runx-cli 0.6.14 confirmed in evidence_json and machine check. GitHub star: machine verifier confirmed @rohitmulani63-ops stars runxhq/runx, starred 2026-06-29. Package name and publish: exact name list-hygiene-judge, published as rohitmulani63-ops/list-hygiene-judge@sha-a3364df6aaa1, public_url live at runx.ai, no secrets in any artifact. PR and raw files: PR 177 against runxhq/runx is live. x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from commit 850f89bd at the PR head, both HTTP 200 with real content. Version consistency: sha-a3364df6aaa1, digest sha256:24fde586..., commit 850f89bd, version 0.1.0 consistent across all artifacts. Harness: local harness passed on Docker Desktop Linux (4 cases, 0 assertion errors). Hosted harness confirmed by machine check: 5 cases, 4 receipts, green. Three required case shapes are present in X.yaml with correct decision states and append counts: sealed_decay_re_permission (recency_days 121 > 90, re_permission, append 1), sealed_hard_bounce_suppress (hard_bounces 1, suppress, append 1), stop_missing_or_stale_evidence (stale evidence, human_review, append 0). Two additional cases also present. Dogfood: post-publish dogfood run produced receipt runx:receipt:sha256:ec5f7ddfb85a204c627a227540896a87361969b160b55e3a6a85f8dd33a95523. verification_json.dogfood.verify_verdict shows valid=true, digest valid, content_address valid, signature valid (mode: production, kid: runx-demo-key), findings empty. This is a real post-publish run, not a harness fixture. Machine check evidence_dogfood_present confirmed the dogfood block exists in evidence_json. Typed inputs and outputs: X.yaml judge runner declares all required inputs including engagement_history, bounce_policy, current_consent_state. SKILL.md declares decision{state,reason} plus recorded_transition and readback. No operational_proposal. Dispatch-free write: graph steps are read_projection, decide, conditional append_event with idempotency_key and expected_version, readback. No proposal, no mint. Stop lanes for human_review do not append. Refusals: SKILL.md Refusals section names all required refusals and harness stop cases demonstrate them. Observations and report: 10 observation items confirmed by machine check, covering CLI version, all case names, suppress reason, stop reason, sealed receipt id, aggregate_id, idempotency_key binding. Report covers 28 bullet items including full dogfood command, verify verdict, and new-user install path. The skill has real operator value: governed consent-state transitions with compare-and-set safety, idempotency protection, and stop lanes for stale or ambiguous evidence are the exact controls a list-hygiene pipeline needs.