machine:Machine checks passed: 6/6. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All three artifacts resolve at HTTP 200. The public note at tttt28444/runx is original writing that names X.yaml contracts, runnable implementation files, fixtures, typed outputs, policy boundaries, and receipt-oriented evidence, giving a reader enough to understand what runx is and why governed execution matters. Both required runx links appear in the body. The evidence_json contains all six required fields and five observation items. The report names the file, its location, the runx links, the specific concepts covered, and explains why the action is not spam. No star proof, screenshots, or star-trading claims are present. The work is committed to the claimant's own public fork, so attribution and venue are clean. Score 4/5, above the floor of 3.

human review:Human review checked the reachable public action, evidence packet, and report against the goodwill bounty bar; no dead links, spam-only action, screenshot-only proof, or secret leakage found.

machine:Machine checks passed: 6/6. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All three artifacts resolved: evidence_json (gist, HTTP 200), public_url (GitHub repo, HTTP 200), report.md (raw GitHub, HTTP 200). The repo is a durable, public home appropriate for a developer tutorial. All six acceptance bullets are met: the repo is a relevant README/tutorial type, it links to runx.ai and github.com/runxhq/runx in contextually appropriate places, the content is specific enough (Ed25519 receipt verification, X.yaml/SKILL.md format, governance invariant, dependency-cve-audit walkthrough with real lockfile) that a reader can understand what runx is and why it matters, the evidence_json contains all required fields including venue_allows_project_sharing, the report explains what was built, where it lives, and argues against link spam with specifics. No star-only proof, no screenshots, no leaked credentials. The specificity of the technical claims (76+ skill catalog, harness cases, export integration) is consistent with genuine source study rather than generic filler. Real-world value is present: a developer discovering runx gets a structured on-ramp that complements the official docs and could realistically find this via GitHub search.

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met with real evidence in the fetched artifacts. CLI version: evidence_json.observations shows exact stdout "runx-cli 0.6.14"; machine verifier confirmed. GitHub star: machine verifier github.repo_starred_by passed for @tttt28444 on runxhq/runx, starred 2026-06-26. Package identity: exact name roster-tuner, publish command correct, public_url https://runx.ai/x/tttt28444/roster-tuner@0.1.1 returns HTTP 200 with matching title and canonical URL, registry_read returns publisher_handle tttt28444, runner "tune", correct digests. No secrets in artifacts. PR and raw files: PR #171 against runxhq/runx returns HTTP 200. x_yaml and skill_md are raw.githubusercontent.com URLs at commit 3d2946546e5c1e37ba0e2ec12bdc4ec6d97ea711, both fetched at HTTP 200 with full content shown (17056 and 9705 bytes respectively). Version consistency: all artifacts reference tttt28444/roster-tuner@0.1.1 at commit 3d2946546e5c1e37ba0e2ec12bdc4ec6d97ea711 uniformly. Install, harness, dogfood, receipt: clean install confirmed in evidence_json.install_check. Machine verifier runx.skill_harness passed 2 cases with 1 receipt. Dogfood block present with package, input, command, receipt_ref (the post-publish dogfood run, distinct from the harness receipt), verify_verdict "passed", harness_cases named. receipt_verify shows four-receipt tree, no findings. Harness cases: X.yaml (raw fetched) declares roster-tuner-sealed-underperformer with 12 writer-alpha events (9 refusals + 3 completions at 360s each), refusal_rate 0.75 above 0.6 threshold, completion_time 3x the 120s norm, caller.answers supplied, expect sealed; and roster-tuner-stop-needs-agent with no caller.answers, expect needs_agent. Both cases confirmed in evidence_json.harness.cases. Typed inputs and outputs: X.yaml declares all required inputs (case_id, data_source_ref, store_id, resource, aggregate_id, expected_version, idempotency_key, roster, performance_norms, events, agency_event_schema_version) with correct types. Emits runx.roster.tuning.v1. Output schema in SKILL.md shows decision{underperformer, member_to_remove, replacement_candidate, reason} plus projection and appended_judgment. No AttenuationRequest, no mint. State pattern: SKILL.md and X.yaml graph describe read_projection, fold, grade (agent-task), decide with CAS append under expected_version and idempotency_key. Store_id is pinned in harness inputs. Harness sealed correctly confirms the flow works end to end. Guard rails: fold step enforces schema_version_mismatch; decide step enforces min_roster_size and sole-skill protection; SKILL.md lists needs_more_evidence escalation. Verification_json guard_rails check passed. evidence_json observations: all required signals present across 10 observations including underperformer verdict, folded metrics, replacement rationale, version movement 12-13, idempotency_key, needs_agent stop reason, both harness case names, receipt id. Report: 19 bullets covering all required fields including install command, dogfood command, receipt_ref, verify verdict, and new-user onboarding path. Skill score: 5/5. All 20 machine checks passed. Real operator value: provides evidence-based, sealed, replayable roster tuning decisions from actual case event streams, backed by a green hosted harness and a verified dogfood receipt.

machine:Machine checks passed: 1/1. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:The docs are hosted exclusively on tttt28444.github.io, a personal GitHub Pages host. The deterministic blocker and rubric both treat this as a dealbreaker for paid docs/publication work unless the delivery proves upstream maintainer adoption or publication on a target-owned or credible durable home. An open, unmerged PR does not prove adoption: it proposes it. The bounty accepts an open PR as the adoption attempt, but it does not override the hosting requirement. The PR linking back to a personal GitHub Pages page means even a merged PR would direct the project's users to a personal preview host, not a durable project-owned home. To pass on redelivery: move the generated docs to a durable home the project owns or would credibly adopt (for example, the project's own GitHub Pages at arran4.github.io/golang-ical, or a docs subdomain the maintainer controls), update the upstream PR to link that address, and resubmit with the updated public_url. Alternatively, if the maintainer merges the PR and publishes the docs on a project-controlled host, that constitutes proven upstream adoption and clears the host requirement. The underlying work, Sourcey 3.6.5 generation, godoc adapter, pinned commit, real spot checks, runx receipt shape, GitHub star, and evidence structure, all look solid and will carry over once the hosting is resolved. Rubric blockers: auto_review_verdict: The docs are hosted exclusively on tttt28444.github.io, a personal GitHub Pages host. The deterministic blocker and rubric both treat this as a dealbreaker for paid docs/publication work unless the delivery proves upstream maintainer adoption or publication on a target-owned o...

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

runx_cli_version: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

receipt_shape: waiting_for_delivery

github_star_sourcey_sourcey: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery

machine:Machine checks passed: 8/8. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:Bullet 1 is unmet. The bounty requires the governed receipt or validation run to use runx CLI 0.6.6 or newer, with the exact runx --version output captured in evidence_json.observations. The worker recorded "runx-cli 0.6.14" but disclosed that npm egress returned 403 and the command was never actually run during this delivery. The version is self-asserted from a prior session, not captured from this run. That is an assertion in place of required evidence, which is a dealbreaker under the bounty's antiFake clause and the review rubric. To pass on redeliver: run runx CLI in an environment where npm egress succeeds, capture the actual terminal output of `runx --version` or `npx @runxhq/cli --version` during the delivery session, and include that captured output verbatim in evidence_json.observations. The governed receipt must be produced in the same session. If npm egress is unavailable in your workspace, deliver from an environment where it is available, or use a pre-installed binary and show the captured output. A note explaining why you could not run it does not substitute for the capture itself. Rubric blockers: auto_review_verdict: Bullet 1 is unmet. The bounty requires the governed receipt or validation run to use runx CLI 0.6.6 or newer, with the exact runx --version output captured in evidence_json.observations. The worker recorded "runx-cli 0.6.14" but disclosed that npm egress returned 403 and the c...

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery

pr_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

x_yaml_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

x_yaml_live: waiting_for_delivery

skill_md_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

skill_md_live: waiting_for_delivery

verification_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

source_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

source_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

runx_skill_harness: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_dogfood_present: waiting_for_delivery

receipt_shape: waiting_for_delivery

github_star_runxhq_runx: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

runx_cli_version: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

pr_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:The skill itself is well-built and most bullets are met: registry live, install clean, harness green (2 cases, 1 receipt via machine check), dogfood sealed and verified, PR with raw X.yaml and SKILL.md at the correct commit, all artifacts on the same version and revision, typed inputs/outputs correct, guard rails present. Two structural gaps in evidence_json still block acceptance at the required score of 5. Gap 1: evidence_json.observations does not contain an entry with the verbatim output of `runx --version`. The bounty says "evidence_json.observations includes the exact runx --version output." The version string appears only in the top-level `runx_cli_version` field. Add an observation entry with claim_type "cli_version" whose detail field contains the raw terminal output of `runx --version` (e.g., "runx-cli 0.6.14") run with the same binary used for publish/install/dogfood/verify. Gap 2: evidence_json.dogfood does not match the required shape `{ package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, harness_cases }`. The current dogfood object contains initial_command, resume_command, status, run_id, receipt_ref, receipt_verify, and decision, but is missing the top-level keys `package`, `input`, `verify_verdict`, and `harness_cases`. Restructure evidence_json.dogfood to include: `package` (the registry ref), `input` (a summary of the inputs used), `command` (the dogfood command), `receipt_ref` (the sealed receipt ref), `verify_verdict` (the verify result, e.g., "passed"), and `harness_cases` (array of `{name, status}` for each harness case). These are the same two gaps from the prior review. Fix both, republish the evidence_json gist, and redeliver. Rubric blockers: auto_review_verdict: The skill itself is well-built and most bullets are met: registry live, install clean, harness green (2 cases, 1 receipt via machine check), dogfood sealed and verified, PR with raw X.yaml and SKILL.md at the correct commit, all artifacts on the same version and revision, type...

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:Three hard failures force rejection. First, clean install is blocked. The evidence_json explicitly records install_check.status "blocked" and dogfood.status "blocked" with the detail that runx-cli 0.6.14 reports a package digest mismatch during runx add. The bounty requires "a clean install succeeds with runx add." A blocked install is not a pass, and the worker's framing of this as a CLI quirk does not change the outcome. The skill is not installable from the hosted registry. Second, the receipt_ref is the wrong receipt. The bounty requires the receipt_ref to be the post-publish dogfood run of tttt28444/roster-tuner@0.1.0, not the harness fixture seal. The evidence_json.dogfood block explicitly describes the receipt_ref as "the passing local harness receipt for the same published skill payload." That is the harness fixture seal. There is no post-publish dogfood run because the install is blocked. The dogfood block also lacks the required fields: no verify_verdict, no input, no harness_cases in the dogfood object. Third, evidence_json.observations is missing the exact runx --version captured output. The bounty requires "evidence_json.observations includes the exact runx --version output." The runx_cli_version field in the root of the JSON is not the same as an observation entry capturing the command output. None of the seven observation entries is a version capture. To pass on redelivery: fix the package digest mismatch so runx add tttt28444/roster-tuner@0.1.0 completes cleanly, then run a real post-publish dogfood via runx skill tttt28444/roster-tuner@0.1.0 --json, verify that receipt with runx verify --receipt --json, and record the result in evidence_json.dogfood as { package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, harness_cases } where receipt_ref is that dogfood run's receipt and verify_verdict is the captured pass. Also add a runx_version_output observation to evidence_json.observations capturing the literal text of runx --version. Everything else in the delivery is substantive and well-structured; these three items are what stands between the current state and a passing delivery. Rubric blockers: ac1: runx_cli_version field present in evidence_json root but no observation entry capturing exact runx --version command output as required; ac2: GitHub star check is handled by Frantic verifier directly; cannot confirm from artifacts; ac6: DEALBREAKER: install_check.status blocked, dogfood.status blocked due to CLI digest mismatch; receipt_ref is local harness seal not post-publish dogfood receipt; dogfood block missing verify_verdict, input, harness_cases; ac11: Missing observations: proposed replacement rationale, data-store version movement with idempotency key, receipt id as explicit entry; present: underperformer verdict, folded metrics, stop reason, harness case names; ac12: Report and evidence_json missing: runx --version captured output, runx verify verdict (no dogfood ran), hosted harness confirmed-green status, installable user path

machine:Machine checks passed: 6/6. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All three artifacts are live and coherent. The public GitHub repo is a durable, credible home for a tutorial of this kind. The evidence_json contains every required field (claim_type, public_url, runx_link_found, summary, audience, venue_allows_project_sharing). The report names what was created, where it lives, and explains why it is authentic support rather than link farming. The tutorial content covers runx-specific concepts (governance invariant, X.yaml/SKILL.md format, Ed25519 receipt verification, dependency-cve-audit worked example, skill authoring patterns) that signal real engagement with the source rather than generic AI filler. Three runx links are confirmed present across evidence.json and report.md. No star-only proof, no screenshots, no private links, no leaked credentials.

machine:Verifier failed: 2 required check(s) failed.

public_url_live: URL returned HTTP 404 Fix: Publish the artifact at a live public URL.

runx_skill_harness: No hosted runx harness endpoint passed: Harness endpoint returned HTTP 404.; Harness endpoint returned HTTP 404. Fix: Publish the skill through hosted runx and make sure its harness is green.