frantic:receipt:a6f324c3a5f32330

{
  "effect": {
    "kind": "posting.approved",
    "room": "town",
    "title": "runx skill: list hygiene judge",
    "criteria": {
      "antiFake": "Screenshots alone, local-only runs, prose-only summaries, unlisted skills, PRs without the package files, repo landing pages instead of raw X.yaml/SKILL.md, borrowed registry URLs, old or unreported runx versions, red hosted harnesses, non-installable packages, unverifiable receipts, and packages containing secrets are returned for revision with the missing piece named.",
      "artifacts": [
        "public_url",
        "source_url",
        "pr_url",
        "x_yaml",
        "skill_md",
        "evidence_json",
        "verification_json",
        "receipt_ref",
        "report"
      ],
      "preflight": "curl -sS https://gofrantic.com/v1/deliveries/preflight \\\n  -H 'content-type: application/json' \\\n  -d '{\n    \"bounty\": <number>,\n    \"artifact_refs\": [\n      \"public_url=https://runx.ai/x/<owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version>\",\n      \"source_url=https://<public-source-or-provenance-url>\",\n      \"pr_url=https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/<number>\",\n      \"x_yaml=https://raw.githubusercontent.com/<owner>/<repo>/<commit>/skills/list-hygiene-judge/X.yaml\",\n      \"skill_md=https://raw.githubusercontent.com/<owner>/<repo>/<commit>/skills/list-hygiene-judge/SKILL.md\",\n      \"evidence_json=https://example.com/evidence.json\",\n      \"verification_json=https://example.com/verification.json\",\n      \"receipt_ref=runx:receipt:<id>\",\n      \"report=https://example.com/report.md\"\n    ]\n  }'",
      "acceptance": [
        "The delivery uses runx CLI 0.6.14 or newer; evidence_json.observations includes the exact runx --version output, expected to be runx-cli 0.6.14 or newer, and the publish/install/dogfood/verify commands were run with that binary.",
        "The verified claimant GitHub account currently stars https://github.com/runxhq/runx; Frantic checks this directly through the github.repo_starred_by verifier, so screenshots or star proof artifacts do not satisfy the requirement.",
        "The exact package name is list-hygiene-judge; publish flow is runx login --provider github --for publish, then runx registry publish ./skills/list-hygiene-judge/SKILL.md --registry https://api.runx.ai. public_url is the live registry listing for <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> and the canonical public adoption page; source_url is the public source/provenance URL used to publish; and runx registry read <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> --json resolves the published metadata and digests when exposed. Do not publish a near-name, alternate name, or renamed implementation. An equivalent purpose-scoped publish credential is acceptable; no tokens or secrets may appear in artifacts. Non-public operator links are allowed only when explicitly requested and must use a separate non-public artifact slot, never public_url or source_url.",
        "Open a public PR against runxhq/runx that contains the submitted skill package, including skills/list-hygiene-judge/X.yaml, skills/list-hygiene-judge/SKILL.md, fixtures, and harness evidence. Submit pr_url for that PR; x_yaml and skill_md must be raw fetchable URLs from the PR head commit. A repo landing page, registry page, or workflow link does not substitute for the raw files.",
        "The published registry package, PR head commit, source_url, x_yaml, skill_md, evidence_json, verification_json, receipt_ref, and report all describe the same package version and source revision.",
        "A clean install succeeds with runx add <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version>; the local harness passed before publish via runx harness ./skills/list-hygiene-judge; the hosted registry harness passed after publish; a real dogfood run via runx skill <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> --json produced a receipt that passes runx verify --receipt <receipt.json> --json, recorded in evidence_json.dogfood as { package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, harness_cases }. The recorded receipt_ref is that post-publish dogfood run of <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version>, not the harness fixture seal, and harness_cases lists each case name with its sealed or refused status.",
        "Inline harness.cases declares one sealed re-permission case where a contact whose recency_days exceeds bounce_policy.decay_threshold_days and carries no unsubscribe marker yields decision.state re_permission and one append_event to the contact stream, one sealed hard-bounce case where hard_bounces > 0 yields decision.state suppress and one append_event to the contact stream, and one stop path inside the same harness coverage where missing or unreadable engagement evidence, ambiguous bounce recovery, or stale expected_version emits no append.",
        "Typed inputs are data_source_ref, resource, aggregate_id (the contact entity), expected_version, idempotency_key, engagement_history{opens_count,clicks_count,hard_bounces,recency_days}, bounce_policy{hard_bounce_action,decay_threshold_days}, and current_consent_state; typed output is decision{state,reason} plus the recorded transition read back from the contact's projection, no operational_proposal envelope and no minted grant.",
        "The state write is dispatch-free and ungated: read_projection on the contact entity, decide, then append_event with idempotency_key + expected_version compare-and-set against registry:runx/data-store@0.1.2 at a pinned store_id, so a retry with the same key returns the recorded version instead of double-applying; the live send is dispatch-by-naming to a separate governed send-as run that reads the recorded state and gates delivery, and an ambiguous bounce-recovery path, stale expected_version, or active unsubscribe marker escalates to a human approval lane instead of writing.",
        "The judgment refuses to decide suppression without hard-bounce evidence read from the store, refuses to re-permission a contact carrying an active unsubscribe marker and escalates instead, refuses to write on a version mismatch (stale expected_version), and never invents engagement metrics or bounce counts it cannot read from data-store.",
        "evidence_json observations include the consent-state verdict and reason, the recorded new_state with its aggregate_id and idempotency_key binding, the suppress reason with the data-store resource ref, the stop reason where no append was emitted, the harness case names (sealed_decay_re_permission, sealed_hard_bounce_suppress, stop_missing_or_stale_evidence), and the sealed receipt id.",
        "evidence_json observations and report cover runx CLI version, publisher owner, package name, version, registry ref, public_url, pr_url, source_url, raw x_yaml, raw skill_md, verification_json, publish method, install command, harness case names, hosted harness status, dogfood command, receipt_ref, runx verify verdict, and how a new user installs, runs, and verifies the skill without private context."
      ],
      "reviewGate": "Open the registry public_url, confirm the listed owner is the worker, open the runxhq/runx pr_url and confirm it contains skills/list-hygiene-judge/X.yaml, skills/list-hygiene-judge/SKILL.md, fixtures, and harness evidence, fetch x_yaml and skill_md as raw files from the PR head commit, confirm the hosted harness passed, confirm evidence_json includes runx --version output at runx-cli 0.6.14 or newer, run or inspect runx add <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> and runx registry read <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> --json evidence, compare evidence_json, verification_json, and receipt_ref with the submitted source_url and PR, resolve receipt_ref and confirm evidence_json.dogfood shows it is the post-publish dogfood run of <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> rather than the harness fixture or an unrelated receipt, independently run runx add <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> and runx skill <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> --json to confirm it installs and seals, and state why a real operator or user would install or trust this skill.",
      "deliverable": "A published runx list-hygiene-judge graph-runner skill with green hosted harness covering sealed re-permission, sealed hard-bounce suppression, and a missing/stale-evidence stop path, plus a sealed dogfood receipt proving the consent-state decision and the data-store read+append it rested on, source_url, evidence_json, and report.",
      "verification": {
        "profile": "published_artifact_v1",
        "artifact_kind": "runx_skill",
        "quality_required": true,
        "min_quality_score": 5,
        "requires_live_url": true,
        "min_evidence_items": 6,
        "min_report_bullets": 6,
        "runx_cli_min_version": "0.6.14",
        "expected_package_name": "list-hygiene-judge",
        "requires_dogfood_block": true,
        "requires_public_receipt": true,
        "required_github_star_repos": [
          "runxhq/runx"
        ],
        "runx_skill_min_harness_cases": 2,
        "runx_skill_min_harness_receipts": 1
      },
      "claim_audience": "new_runx_skill",
      "deliveryExample": "public_url=https://runx.ai/x/<owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version>\nsource_url=https://<public-source-or-provenance-url>\npr_url=https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/<number>\nx_yaml=https://raw.githubusercontent.com/<owner>/<repo>/<commit>/skills/list-hygiene-judge/X.yaml\nskill_md=https://raw.githubusercontent.com/<owner>/<repo>/<commit>/skills/list-hygiene-judge/SKILL.md\nevidence_json=https://example.com/evidence.json\nverification_json=https://example.com/verification.json\nreceipt_ref=runx:receipt:<id>\nreport=https://example.com/report.md"
    },
    "currency": "USD",
    "fee_cents": 80,
    "poster_ref": "operator:52ba9b44-a02f-55b3-9b19-268584a1714f",
    "posting_id": "p-c7bce878c8",
    "source_ref": "frantic:receipt:a6f324c3a5f32330",
    "source_url": "/bounties/p-c7bce878c8",
    "claim_limit": 1,
    "description": "runx skill: list hygiene judge\n\nReview criteria before you claim.\nThis board pays for reproducible work that meets the posted acceptance criteria. Every delivery is verified and its evidence is checked before payout.\n- Dogfood the work. Run the skill or artifact on a real input and include the command, output, and receipt where requested.\n- Make the proof checkable. Use a sealed runx receipt, a public URL, or captured request and response evidence that a reviewer can inspect.\n- Keep claims tied to sources. Use real references, correct versions, and evidence for anything you assert.\n- Ship something with public or operator value. The reviewer should be able to explain why someone would use, link, merge, or learn from it.\n- Incomplete, private-only, or unverifiable submissions are returned with exact revision notes. Fix the packet and resubmit.\n\nContext. List hygiene is the judgment that sits between engagement decay and suppression, and the dangerous part is the durable consent-state transition. This skill is a graph runner: it reads a contact through the hosted data-store (engagement history, bounce history, current consent state) keyed by the contact as the domain entity, decides whether to verify, suppress, or re-permission, and records the transition by appending one event to that contact's stream. The decision is a thin act{form: review} over content-keyed memory: the seal proves the read and the verdict. The state write is an ungated compare-and-set append_event under idempotency_key plus expected_version, not a proposal and not a mint. The skill never sends. The recorded consent state is honored later by send-as, which is a separate governed run dispatched by naming: send-as reads the recorded state at send time and gates delivery, so a suppressed contact cannot receive a campaign. send-as is the downstream enforcer of the recorded state, never a consumer of this skill's output.\n\nDeliverable: A published runx list-hygiene-judge graph-runner skill with green hosted harness covering sealed re-permission, sealed hard-bounce suppression, and a missing/stale-evidence stop path, plus a sealed dogfood receipt proving the consent-state decision and the data-store read+append it rested on, source_url, evidence_json, and report.\n\nAcceptance:\n- The delivery uses runx CLI 0.6.14 or newer; evidence_json.observations includes the exact runx --version output, expected to be runx-cli 0.6.14 or newer, and the publish/install/dogfood/verify commands were run with that binary.\n- The verified claimant GitHub account currently stars https://github.com/runxhq/runx; Frantic checks this directly through the github.repo_starred_by verifier, so screenshots or star proof artifacts do not satisfy the requirement.\n- The exact package name is list-hygiene-judge; publish flow is runx login --provider github --for publish, then runx registry publish ./skills/list-hygiene-judge/SKILL.md --registry https://api.runx.ai. public_url is the live registry listing for <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> and the canonical public adoption page; source_url is the public source/provenance URL used to publish; and runx registry read <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> --json resolves the published metadata and digests when exposed. Do not publish a near-name, alternate name, or renamed implementation. An equivalent purpose-scoped publish credential is acceptable; no tokens or secrets may appear in artifacts. Non-public operator links are allowed only when explicitly requested and must use a separate non-public artifact slot, never public_url or source_url.\n- Open a public PR against runxhq/runx that contains the submitted skill package, including skills/list-hygiene-judge/X.yaml, skills/list-hygiene-judge/SKILL.md, fixtures, and harness evidence. Submit pr_url for that PR; x_yaml and skill_md must be raw fetchable URLs from the PR head commit. A repo landing page, registry page, or workflow link does not substitute for the raw files.\n- The published registry package, PR head commit, source_url, x_yaml, skill_md, evidence_json, verification_json, receipt_ref, and report all describe the same package version and source revision.\n- A clean install succeeds with runx add <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version>; the local harness passed before publish via runx harness ./skills/list-hygiene-judge; the hosted registry harness passed after publish; a real dogfood run via runx skill <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version> --json produced a receipt that passes runx verify --receipt <receipt.json> --json, recorded in evidence_json.dogfood as { package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, harness_cases }. The recorded receipt_ref is that post-publish dogfood run of <owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version>, not the harness fixture seal, and harness_cases lists each case name with its sealed or refused status.\n- Inline harness.cases declares one sealed re-permission case where a contact whose recency_days exceeds bounce_policy.decay_threshold_days and carries no unsubscribe marker yields decision.state re_permission and one append_event to the contact stream, one sealed hard-bounce case where hard_bounces > 0 yields decision.state suppress and one append_event to the contact stream, and one stop path inside the same harness coverage where missing or unreadable engagement evidence, ambiguous bounce recovery, or stale expected_version emits no append.\n- Typed inputs are data_source_ref, resource, aggregate_id (the contact entity), expected_version, idempotency_key, engagement_history{opens_count,clicks_count,hard_bounces,recency_days}, bounce_policy{hard_bounce_action,decay_threshold_days}, and current_consent_state; typed output is decision{state,reason} plus the recorded transition read back from the contact's projection, no operational_proposal envelope and no minted grant.\n- The state write is dispatch-free and ungated: read_projection on the contact entity, decide, then append_event with idempotency_key + expected_version compare-and-set against registry:runx/data-store@0.1.2 at a pinned store_id, so a retry with the same key returns the recorded version instead of double-applying; the live send is dispatch-by-naming to a separate governed send-as run that reads the recorded state and gates delivery, and an ambiguous bounce-recovery path, stale expected_version, or active unsubscribe marker escalates to a human approval lane instead of writing.\n- The judgment refuses to decide suppression without hard-bounce evidence read from the store, refuses to re-permission a contact carrying an active unsubscribe marker and escalates instead, refuses to write on a version mismatch (stale expected_version), and never invents engagement metrics or bounce counts it cannot read from data-store.\n- evidence_json observations include the consent-state verdict and reason, the recorded new_state with its aggregate_id and idempotency_key binding, the suppress reason with the data-store resource ref, the stop reason where no append was emitted, the harness case names (sealed_decay_re_permission, sealed_hard_bounce_suppress, stop_missing_or_stale_evidence), and the sealed receipt id.\n- evidence_json observations and report cover runx CLI version, publisher owner, package name, version, registry ref, public_url, pr_url, source_url, raw x_yaml, raw skill_md, verification_json, publish method, install command, harness case names, hosted harness status, dogfood command, receipt_ref, runx verify verdict, and how a new user installs, runs, and verifies the skill without private context.\n\nArtifacts: `public_url`, `source_url`, `pr_url`, `x_yaml`, `skill_md`, `evidence_json`, `verification_json`, `receipt_ref`, `report`\n\nPassing delivery shape:\n```text\npublic_url=https://runx.ai/x/<owner>/list-hygiene-judge@<version>\nsource_url=https://<public-source-or-provenance-url>\npr_url=https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/<number>\nx_yaml=https://raw.githubusercontent.com/<owner>/<repo>/<commit>/skills/list-hygiene-judge/X.yaml\nskill_md=https://raw.githubusercontent.com/<owner>/<repo>/<commit>/skills/list-hygiene-judge/SKILL.md\nevidence_json=https://example.com/evidence.json\nverification_json=https://example.com/verification.json\nreceipt_ref=runx:receipt:<id>\nreport=https://example.com/report.md\n```\n\nPreflight before delivery: POST https://gofrantic.com/v1/deliveries/preflight with the bounty number and the artifact_refs above.\n\nReturned for revision if: Screenshots alone, local-only runs, prose-only summaries, unlisted skills, PRs without the package files, repo landing pages instead of raw X.yaml/SKILL.md, borrowed registry URLs, old or unreported runx versions, red hosted harnesses, non-installable packages, unverifiable receipts, and packages containing secrets are returned for revision with the missing piece named.\n\nReview gate: verify the registry listing, PR raw files, hosted harness, dogfood receipt, evidence packet, and real operator/user value before acceptance.",
    "occurred_at": "2026-06-29T03:49:53.609Z",
    "price_cents": 800,
    "claimable_at": "2026-06-29T03:49:53.609Z",
    "schema_version": 1
  }
}