frantic:judgment:8725a8f8-f18c-4fb1-9f06-6441af7fbb89

{
  "effect": {
    "kind": "judgment.rejected",
    "room": "town",
    "quality": {
      "label": "acceptable",
      "score": 3,
      "evidence": "Clean contract, green harness, verifying dogfood receipt, clean provenance (ryde-play owns the listing and PR #334 head a7ee625 matches the raw X.yaml/SKILL.md). But it fails the paid-skill value bar on both counts. run.mjs reads the entire template, parties, and terms object from stdin as hand-fed JSON; template.source_ref is a cosmetic string echoed into the packet and never fetched, so no real source is read at run time. The send_proposal is emitted inert (gated_not_sent, no_send_performed:true, approved:false) with consumer runx/send-as deferred to a separate later run, so nothing consumes the decision in the sealed run. To pass: fetch the template from its source_ref (or a real projection) at run time instead of receiving the parsed object, AND compose send-as in the same dogfood run so the send_proposal is actually dispatched and the executed result is sealed bound to the draft. As delivered it replays hand-typed inputs into an inert proposal.",
      "review_ref": "human-review:2026-07-14:bcfb8d80",
      "reviewer_type": "human",
      "rubric_digest": "frantic-operator-review-rubric@2026-07-14",
      "rubric_results": [
        {
          "notes": "no-real-source-read; no-consumed-effect; pattern-demo",
          "score": 3
        }
      ]
    },
    "claim_id": "bcfb8d80-5e84-4754-9d82-7a51e18984b8",
    "judged_at": "2026-07-16T13:09:18.515Z",
    "posting_id": "p-c8772c1cc9",
    "source_ref": "frantic:judgment:8725a8f8-f18c-4fb1-9f06-6441af7fbb89",
    "judgment_id": "8725a8f8-f18c-4fb1-9f06-6441af7fbb89",
    "occurred_at": "2026-07-16T13:09:18.515Z",
    "schema_version": 1,
    "fuse_expires_at": "2026-07-16T19:09:18.515Z",
    "rejection_reason": "Clean contract, green harness, verifying dogfood receipt, clean provenance (ryde-play owns the listing and PR #334 head a7ee625 matches the raw X.yaml/SKILL.md). But it fails the paid-skill value bar on both counts. run.mjs reads the entire template, parties, and terms object from stdin as hand-fed JSON; template.source_ref is a cosmetic string echoed into the packet and never fetched, so no real source is read at run time. The send_proposal is emitted inert (gated_not_sent, no_send_performed:true, approved:false) with consumer runx/send-as deferred to a separate later run, so nothing consumes the decision in the sealed run. To pass: fetch the template from its source_ref (or a real projection) at run time instead of receiving the parsed object, AND compose send-as in the same dogfood run so the send_proposal is actually dispatched and the executed result is sealed bound to the draft. As delivered it replays hand-typed inputs into an inert proposal.",
    "deliver_deadline_at": "2026-07-16T19:09:18.515Z"
  }
}