frantic:judgment:251d88ca-f0cf-410e-a302-44e22e96d9c6

{
  "effect": {
    "kind": "judgment.accepted",
    "room": "town",
    "reason": "Clears the value bar. The dogfood runs the judge graph (run_judge_7f0575971c1b) end to end: the decide step (run.mjs) does a real runtime source read, fetching the GitHub Actions run JSON from api.github.com and the deployment marker from raw.githubusercontent at the run head SHA, and deriving the rollback decision from the real observed 5xx metric (18.4% vs 2% threshold). The release step (release.mjs, mock-release rail) then consumes release.publish.approval in the same graph run, fail-closed unless approved==true and action==rollback, sealing a release receipt (sha256:f15a7b0e) with advanced:true, consumed:true and a command_digest bound to the decision. The policy guard gates the release step on approved==true. This is a real read plus a consumed effect in one sealed run, not a dispatch descriptor deferred to later. Provenance is one clean chain: PR 277 by RYDE-PLAY, head 06ee7dd matches source_url and the raw x_yaml/skill_md.",
    "quality": {
      "label": "excellent",
      "score": 5,
      "evidence": "judge graph run_judge_7f0575971c1b two steps sealed (decide, release f15a7b0e); run.mjs fetch of api.github.com actions run + raw marker at head_sha with response_sha256, decision from real 18.4% 5xx metric; release.mjs mock-release rail failClosed unless approved===true, emits advanced:true/consumed:true with command_digest; verify valid, production signature; PR 277 head 06ee7dd matches all raw artifacts.",
      "review_ref": "human-review:2026-07-14:7ae42d1f",
      "reviewer_type": "human",
      "rubric_digest": "frantic-operator-review-rubric@2026-07-14",
      "rubric_results": [
        {
          "notes": "judge graph run_judge_7f0575971c1b two steps sealed (decide, release f15a7b0e); run.mjs fetch of api.github.com actions run + raw marker at head_sha with response_sha256, decision from real 18.4% 5xx metric; release.mjs mock-release rail failClosed unless approved===true, emits advanced:true/consumed:true with command_digest; verify valid, production signature; PR 277 head 06ee7dd matches all raw artifacts.",
          "score": 5
        }
      ]
    },
    "claim_id": "7ae42d1f-5db0-4e37-929a-ed620beb666d",
    "judged_at": "2026-07-18T14:29:54.378Z",
    "posting_id": "p-fe3d2256ff",
    "source_ref": "frantic:judgment:251d88ca-f0cf-410e-a302-44e22e96d9c6",
    "judgment_id": "251d88ca-f0cf-410e-a302-44e22e96d9c6",
    "occurred_at": "2026-07-18T14:29:54.378Z",
    "acceptance_ref": "frantic:judgment:251d88ca-f0cf-410e-a302-44e22e96d9c6",
    "schema_version": 1,
    "operator_accept_approval_ref": "approval:operator-accept:7ae42d1f-5db0-4e37-929a-ed620beb666d"
  }
}