machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets clear against the fetched artifacts. CLI version: runx-cli 0.7.1 observed in evidence_json, machine check passed. GitHub star: machine verifier confirmed @wilber123451-design stars runxhq/runx as of 2026-07-14T17:16:13Z. Package and registry: exact name bookkeeper, published as wilber123451-design/bookkeeper@sha-c58adbf5a9b8, public_url live at runx.ai with matching title and description, no tokens in artifacts. PR and raw files: pr_url https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/326 returned HTTP 200. x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from pinned commit 39fcc6afcbb54d14ca3a58b322e6c48283c2fb94, both returned HTTP 200 with correct skill content. Artifact coherence: all nine artifacts reference bookkeeper 0.1.0, wilber123451-design, sha-c58adbf5a9b8, PR 326, and the same commit SHA. Dogfood and receipt: evidence_json.dogfood contains package, input, command, receipt_ref (sha256:7334..., distinct from the two harness fixture receipts sha256:ece5... and sha256:e0ce...), verify_verdict valid, and both harness cases with sealed/refused status. verification_json confirms digest and content_address match, verdict valid. Harness: machine check passed 2 cases with 2 receipts. X.yaml defines bookkeeper-clean-batch-seals expecting sealed and bookkeeper-ambiguous-needs-review-refusal expecting failure; evidence_json confirms sealed and refused_without_ledger_mutation respectively. Typed I/O: transactions[], chart_of_accounts, prior_period as required JSON inputs; categorized[], anomalies[], reconciliation{matched,unmatched} as outputs, declared in both SKILL.md and X.yaml. Read-only: ledger_mutation_performed false, read_only true, invented_accounts false. Evidence completeness: observations array has 24 items covering all required fields including new_user_flow, categorized_count 3, anomaly_count 1, reconciliation totals, needs_review reason, harness case names, receipt id. Report has 24 bullets covering the same. Claimant provenance: skill authored and published from wilber123451-design's own repo and account; PR is claimant-to-venue, not pointing at pre-existing venue work. Operator value: a real operator holding exported transaction batches and a chart of accounts can install this skill and get a governed, read-only categorization packet for human review without touching a live ledger.

human review:Two independent failures. First, the dogfood receipt is sealed under the dev skeleton identity (issuer local, kid runtime-skeleton, placeholder signature) with a harness subject, and evidence records verify_verdict as the bare string 'valid' with no captured runx verify output; a skeleton-sealed receipt cannot pass production verification and is exactly the dev-seal shortcut this board does not pay. Second, the skill fails the value bar: keyword matching over a hand-fed transactions array against hand-typed chart keywords, the dogfood input is literally the harness fixture, no real source is read, and the outputs are data nothing consumes. To pass: rerun the post-publish dogfood with a production receipt-signing key and submit the runtime run receipt plus the full runx verify verdict JSON, and make the skill do real work at run time (read transactions from a real composed source or wire reconciliation into a consumer).