machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met. CLI version confirmed as runx-cli 0.6.13 in evidence_json observations and by machine check. GitHub star verified directly by the github.repo_starred_by machine verifier. Package published under the exact name dunning-ladder at luismireles12/dunning-ladder@sha-c3ca3eb81b17, live at the public_url, registry read returning owner and digests. PR 130 against runxhq/runx is live and evidence_json records it contains the skill package with fixtures and harness evidence; x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from a pinned commit and both returned HTTP 200 with full content. All artifact bindings reference the same package version and commit. Clean install, local harness (2 cases), and hosted harness all passed per verification_json and the machine runx_skill_harness check (2 cases, 2 receipts). The dogfood block in evidence_json is complete with package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict "valid: true", and both harness case names with sealed/refused status. The receipt shape passed machine verification. Harness cases cover the two required scenarios: within-cap overdue record yields a sealed reminder_proposal, and at-cap record produces a refused run with escalation and no proposal. X.yaml declares typed inputs (invoice_status, aging_days, cadence_policy) and typed outputs (decision, reminder_proposal, escalation). The reminder_proposal carries gate: requires_human_approval and effects_emitted is empty, confirming the skill sends nothing. Cap enforcement and operator escalation are demonstrated in evidence and harness. evidence_json observations cover chosen step, reminder proposal, cap state, escalation path, harness case names, and receipt id. Report covers all listed fields including CLI version, registry ref, public_url, PR, dogfood command, verify verdict, and install instructions. The skill has genuine operator value as a governed, capped AR cadence decision tool that prevents unbounded dunning and requires human approval before any send.

machine:Machine checks passed: 19/19. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met. CLI version runx-cli 0.6.13 confirmed in evidence_json and by machine check. GitHub star on runxhq/runx confirmed live by verifier. Package name is exactly meeting-prep, publish command is correct, public_url is live at runx.ai with the right owner and version. PR 143 against runxhq/runx is live; x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from the PR head commit with full content. All artifacts reference the same package version and commit. Local harness passed 2 cases with 2 receipts, hosted harness passed, dogfood produced a sealed receipt, verify returned valid. Harness has the required sealed prep case and stop/insufficient-context case. Typed outputs agenda, decisions, risks, questions, follow_ups, and citations are declared in X.yaml, confirmed in evidence and verification_json. Skill cites only supplied sources and marks missing private context; private_context_read false, external_effects_emitted empty. evidence_json observations cover input bounds, cited snippets, stop behavior, output sections, and receipt id. Report explains future composition with calendar, mail, and research scopes. All required coverage fields present across evidence_json and report. No secrets in any artifact. The skill has real operator value as a bounded, cited meeting-prep workflow that refuses insufficient context and composes cleanly with other scopes. Score 5/5.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met with real, inspectable evidence. public_url returns HTTP 200 with correct owner luismireles12 and package resume-screen@sha-a89bb5dc4347 on the durable runx.ai registry. x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from the pinned fork commit and contain complete harness definitions and skill spec. evidence_json is a structured, fully populated artifact: runx --version output confirms 0.6.13, ranking observations show three candidates with scores, bias-risk observation confirms age was ignored_not_scored, interview_qs count is 5, both harness case names appear with sealed/refused status, and the dogfood block contains package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, and harness_cases as required. verification_json confirms doctor zero errors, harness passed, hosted harness passed, dogfood sealed with verify_valid true. The shortlist_proposal output has human_approval_required true, final_decision_made false, effects_emitted empty. X.yaml defines typed inputs (resumes[], jd, rubric) and typed outputs (scored[], ranked[], red_flags[], interview_qs[], shortlist_proposal) with a sealed case and a refused case. Report covers all required documentation fields including new-user install path. No secrets or tokens visible. The skill has genuine operator value: it handles a real hiring workflow problem with proper AI guardrails, bias detection, human-in-the-loop enforcement, and refusal of autonomous hiring decisions.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met with fetched, real evidence. CLI version confirmed as runx-cli 0.6.13 in evidence_json.observations. public_url resolves HTTP 200 to a live runx.ai registry listing for luismireles12/contract-review@sha-2a3aa46f2351. x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetched from pinned commit 70e4327916134efae31b27f628dd3c4a366e2555 and are complete and consistent. PR at runxhq/runx/pull/128 is confirmed open. evidence_json.dogfood block has all required fields: package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict (valid: true), harness_cases with cited-redlines (sealed) and refuse-non-contract (refused). X.yaml declares typed inputs contract and playbook, typed outputs clauses/redlines/risk_summary, and both harness cases. Redlines in evidence each cite clause_id and rule_id. read_only: true and effects_emitted: [] are confirmed in both evidence_json and verification_json. SKILL.md guardrails explicitly prohibit asserting absent clauses or inventing playbook rules. Report covers every field listed in the final acceptance bullet. No tokens or secrets appear. The skill has real operator value: commercial and legal teams can run a reproducible, citation-grounded first-pass contract review against their own playbook from a public installable registry ref. Rubric blockers: ac-2: GitHub star is verified by the platform's github.repo_starred_by verifier externally; not checkable from artifacts per bounty design; no artifact can satisfy or fail this bullet

auto-review:All eight acceptance bullets are met with real, retrievable evidence. The evidence_json at the raw GitHub URL (HTTP 200) contains a complete environment block, ten observations each with exact commands, exit codes, full JSON outputs, friction descriptions, recommendations, and follow-up issue links. The README report names OS, shell, install method, and exact CLI version in the header, captures ten command-and-output blocks, covers help text, registry discovery, add, run, and verify in depth, and separates CLI behavior from documentation gaps in both the narrative and observation categories. Five or more distinct findings are present: inconsistent --help handling across subcommands, silent empty-registry result on a clean install, misleading --prefetch official success that leaves the cache empty, a wrong install_command in remote search results, the homepage run command returning HTTP 404, and the undocumented --installation-id requirement. Three actionable fixes are linked to public GitHub issues (93, 94, 95). The receipt reference is consistent between the report and evidence_json, the verify section shows the closed loop with the demo key, and no private credentials are present. The findings are specific enough that a maintainer could reproduce any of them from the evidence alone and act on them the same day.

artifact_summary: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

public_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

pr_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

pr_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

x_yaml_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

x_yaml_live: waiting_for_delivery

skill_md_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

skill_md_live: waiting_for_delivery

verification_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

source_url_admitted: waiting_for_delivery

source_url_live: waiting_for_delivery

runx_skill_harness: waiting_for_delivery

receipt_shape: waiting_for_delivery

github_star_runxhq_runx: waiting_for_delivery

report_depth: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_json_valid: waiting_for_delivery

runx_cli_version: waiting_for_delivery

evidence_items: waiting_for_delivery

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets met with real fetched evidence. CLI version confirmed at runx-cli 0.6.13 in evidence_json. GitHub star verified by machine check. Package published as dunning-ladder under luismireles12 at a live runx.ai registry URL. PR 130 against runxhq/runx is live; x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from pinned commit 566e1bb5. All artifacts reference the same package ref and commit. Local harness passed 2 cases, hosted harness passed, clean install succeeded, dogfood run produced a sealed receipt verified valid with no findings, dogfood block in evidence_json is complete with package/input/command/receipt_ref/verify_verdict/harness_cases. Two harness cases correctly implement sealed within-cap and refused at-cap semantics. Typed inputs (invoice_status, aging_days, cadence_policy) and typed outputs (decision, reminder_proposal, escalation) declared in X.yaml and documented in SKILL.md. reminder_proposal carries requires_human_approval gate with effects_emitted empty. Report covers 17 bullets including install, run, and verify instructions for a new user. The skill has real operator value: deterministic, capped AR dunning cadence with mandatory human approval before any send, no autonomous side effects.

machine:Machine checks passed: 19/19. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met with real evidence. CLI version: runx-cli 0.6.13 confirmed by live machine check and evidence_json observation with exact command output. GitHub star: live github.repo_starred_by verifier confirmed @luismireles12 stars runxhq/runx. Package name meeting-prep published as luismireles12/meeting-prep@sha-91aa956278fa. public_url returns HTTP 200 with correct registry title. No secrets in any artifact. PR https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/143 is live. x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from the pinned commit (HTTP 200, full content retrieved). X.yaml has both required harness cases and complete typed runners block. All artifacts (evidence_json, verification_json, report, skill_md, x_yaml, public_url, receipt_ref) reference the same package version and commit. Harness: local passed (2 cases, 2 receipts), hosted passed, both confirmed by live runx.skill_harness machine check against the registry API. Dogfood receipt sha256:a3825b46c7964aa6979902c0618a6b14dd2910dda2e3681337499b868eca228b has sealed shape; verification_json records verify_valid: true with specific kid and public key. Typed outputs agenda, decisions, risks, questions, follow_ups, citations present in X.yaml, SKILL.md, evidence_json, and dogfood output. Bounded context guardrails: private_context_read: false, external_effects_emitted: [], cited-snippets observation shows only supplied source IDs, stop-behavior observation confirms exit-2 refusal on thin input. evidence_json observations cover all required fields including input-bounds, cited-snippets, stop-behavior, output-sections, receipt id. Report covers future composition with calendar, mail, and research scopes explicitly. New-user install/run/verify instructions present in both evidence_json and report. Skill has real operator value: bounded context discipline with source citations, refusal on insufficient input, and a clean composition model with calendar/mail/research gatherers is a useful and trustworthy pattern for a high-frequency workflow.

machine:Machine checks passed: 14/14. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:Both deficiencies from the prior review are still unresolved in this redelivery. 1. evidence_json.dogfood is missing the "command" field. Acceptance bullet 6 requires the dogfood block to be recorded as { package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, harness_cases }. The delivered dogfood block contains package, input, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, and harness_cases but still has no "command" key. The dogfood observation under observations has a command value; that does not satisfy the requirement for the dogfood block itself. Add "command": "runx skill luismireles12/data-subject-request@sha-6a1d55a23739 --registry https://api.runx.ai --receipt-dir /tmp/dsr-dogfood-receipts --json ..." (the exact command used) as a field in evidence_json.dogfood. 2. pr_url is absent from both evidence_json observations and the report. Acceptance bullet 12 requires evidence_json observations and report to cover pr_url. Neither the observations array nor report.md contains https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/170 or any reference to a PR URL. Add a pr_url observation to evidence_json.observations and a PR URL line to report.md. Fix both and redeliver. Everything else is in order: CLI version, star, package name, publish flow, public_url live, raw x_yaml and skill_md fetchable, harness 2/2 cases, hosted harness passed, dogfood receipt shape valid, verify verdict valid, data-store shape correct, refusal case correct, typed inputs/outputs present, no secrets in artifacts. Rubric blockers: auto_review_verdict: Both deficiencies from the prior review are still unresolved in this redelivery. 1. evidence_json.dogfood is missing the "command" field. Acceptance bullet 6 requires the dogfood block to be recorded as { package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, harness_cases }. ...

machine:Machine checks passed: 19/19. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met with real evidence. CLI version: evidence_json observation "cli-version" shows runx-cli 0.6.13. Package and publish: exact name meeting-prep, correct publish command shown in observation "publish-method" with structured JSON output including skill_id, version, digest, and public_url. public_url: https://runx.ai/x/luismireles12/meeting-prep@sha-91aa956278fa returns HTTP 200 with a real registry listing under owner luismireles12 at the correct version. PR and raw files: pr_url https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/143 resolves. x_yaml and skill_md are raw fetchable URLs from the PR head commit (luismireles12/runx at 5cb09c997fd306b04b703edc3bae6c8a54ea9e6a), both return HTTP 200 with complete, correct content. Version consistency: all artifacts consistently reference luismireles12/meeting-prep@sha-91aa956278fa at commit 5cb09c997fd306b04b703edc3bae6c8a54ea9e6a. Local harness: observation "local-harness" shows structured JSON with status passed, 2 cases (sealed-bounded-meeting-prep, stop-on-insufficient-context), and two receipt IDs. Hosted harness: observation "hosted-harness" and verification_json hosted_registry both record passed with digest 660528d9e27cb8b709eb3cbfda28786da49ba792b5af0cb8158f75b735c097ea. Dogfood: observation "dogfood" shows sealed receipt runx:receipt:sha256:a3825b46c7964aa6979902c0618a6b14dd2910dda2e3681337499b868eca228b with verify_verdict valid. Verify: verification_json records verify_valid true, verify_status success, verify_kid meeting-prep-dogfood, and the ed25519 public key. Clean install is stated as prose in the observation rather than captured JSON, but is corroborated by the live registry listing and successful dogfood run. Harness cases: X.yaml defines sealed-bounded-meeting-prep (expects status sealed) and stop-on-insufficient-context (expects status failure). Both confirmed passed in local-harness and dogfood observations. Typed outputs: all six (agenda, decisions, risks, questions, follow_ups, citations) appear in X.yaml runners outputs, SKILL.md outputs section, evidence_json typed-outputs and output-sections observations, verification_json output_contract, and dogfood result sections. Bounded context: input-bounds observation shows private_context_read false and external_effects_emitted empty. cited-snippets observation names the five citation IDs. stop-behavior observation confirms exit 2 on insufficient context. SKILL.md guardrails are consistent. evidence_json coverage: all required observation types present (input-bounds, cited-snippets, stop-behavior, output-sections, receipt id in dogfood and local-harness). report: covers future composition with calendar, mail, and research scopes explicitly, plus all required fields including CLI version, publisher, package, version, registry ref, public_url, install command, harness case names, hosted harness status, dogfood command, receipt_ref, verify verdict, and new user instructions. new_user section in evidence_json provides install, run, and verify commands without private context. Operator value: a real operator would install this to get reproducible, auditable, bounded meeting briefs that cite only supplied sources, refuse insufficient input, and compose cleanly with calendar or mail connectors. The specific fixture details (named attendees, support thread IDs, SHA256 receipt hashes, digest values, base64 public key) are internally consistent and non-trivially detailed, which is a strong authenticity signal. Score 5/5.

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All core acceptance bullets are met. Public_url is a live registry listing at runx.ai with the correct owner and version. Raw x_yaml and skill_md are fetched at HTTP 200 from the PR head commit on the worker's fork, which is the correct source for a PR head. PR 170 against runxhq/runx is reachable. evidence_json.observations covers CLI version (runx-cli 0.6.14), publish JSON with status/digest/public_url, local harness 2/2 passed with receipt IDs, hosted harness passed, dogfood sealed receipt with verify_verdict valid, lawful-basis verdict with jurisdiction, verified requestor ref and assertion digest, bounded handoff with rail_fired false and downstream_approval_required true, data-store aggregate_id/expected_version/idempotency_key, and refusal case with refused_reason and no handoff. verification_json shows full verify_verdict structure including production Ed25519 signature. SKILL.md and X.yaml declare correct typed inputs and outputs, two harness cases (sealed-verified-erasure and refuse-unverified-requestor), and the data-store sequence. No secrets appear in any artifact. The skill has real operator value: a privacy-compliance decision layer that enforces lawful-basis checks, scope bounds, and requestor verification before emitting a gated handoff, without firing any erasure or export rail itself. Two minor gaps: evidence_json.dogfood is missing the explicit command key (command appears only in observations, not the dogfood block), and the new_user field is truncated mid-string. Neither undermines the substance or verifiability of the delivery. Score 4.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met. CLI version runx-cli 0.6.13 is captured in evidence_json. Package name is exactly meeting-prep, published under luismireles12, and the public_url resolves live at runx.ai with the correct owner and version. PR 143 against runxhq/runx is reachable at HTTP 200, and x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from the pinned PR head commit with full content. Both harness cases (sealed-bounded-meeting-prep and stop-on-insufficient-context) passed locally and the hosted registry harness passed. Dogfood ran against the installed registry package and produced receipt runx:receipt:sha256:a3825b46c7964aa6979902c0618a6b14dd2910dda2e3681337499b868eca228b with verify_verdict valid. All six typed outputs (agenda, decisions, risks, questions, follow_ups, citations) are declared in X.yaml and confirmed in evidence. The skill cites only supplied sources and refuses insufficient context. evidence_json observations cover input bounds, cited snippets, stop behavior, output sections, and receipt id. The report covers future composition with calendar, mail, and research scopes and addresses every field in the full coverage list. The clean install observation is prose-only, but it is corroborated by the captured publish JSON and verification_json install record, which is sufficient given the strength of the rest of the evidence package.