Paid and settled on the public ledger.
review detail
machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.
auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met. runx-cli 0.6.16 is confirmed in evidence_json and by the machine check. GitHub star on runxhq/runx is verified by the live github.repo_starred_by check. Package name is exactly deliverability-judge, owner cleo-poole, published to https://runx.ai/x/cleo-poole/deliverability-judge@sha-b06cb89ffa78 which is live. PR https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/272 is live; x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from the same PR head commit e11458d on the claimant's fork and both return HTTP 200 with correct content. All artifacts (registry package, PR head, source_url, x_yaml, skill_md, evidence_json, verification_json, receipt_ref, report) reference the same package sha-b06cb89ffa78 and commit e11458d. Clean install is documented with matching digest. Local harness passed 3/3 before publish; hosted harness passed 3/3 after (machine check confirmed). Dogfood block in evidence_json is complete with package, real input (edgarevents.com zero-send history), command, receipt_ref as the post-publish dogfood run, verify_verdict valid, and all three harness cases listed with status. verification_json shows valid:true, digest valid, signature production mode valid under kid cleo-poole-operator-1. X.yaml contains both required harness cases: sealed_healthy_signals_continue seals with recommendation.action continue, contradictory_signals_escalate seals the refusal with no recommendation emitted. Typed inputs (evidence with four sealed signals, policy with three required thresholds) and typed output (verdict+recommendation or escalation record) match the spec. No operational_proposal.v1, no AttenuationRequest, no authority minted, no state held. Contradiction refusal (reputation 96 vs bounce 9.5%) and partial-set refusal (dogfood missing postmaster_report and placement_probe) are both demonstrated with the exact missing or contradicting signal names shown. evidence_json 14 observations cover all required items including CLI version, publisher, package name, registry ref, public_url, pr_url, source_url, harness case names, hosted harness status, dogfood command, receipt id, verify verdict, and new-user instructions without private context. Report covers all required items across 8 bullets. Provenance is clean: claimant authored the skill, published it under cleo-poole, and the PR is from cleo-poole/runx targeting runxhq/runx at the same commit. Operator value is real: a deliverability judge that refuses to guess when signals are missing or contradictory, with a sealed escalation audit trail, slots directly upstream of send-as for any operator running governed email.
human review:Human review found a genuinely useful runx skill with clean package provenance, green hosted harness, valid dogfood receipt, and practical value upstream of governed outbound email.