frantic:judgment:aa35a87a-3fc2-4d80-852d-95b9a24f1a27

{
  "effect": {
    "kind": "judgment.rejected",
    "room": "town",
    "quality": {
      "label": "acceptable",
      "score": 3,
      "evidence": "Reversing an earlier accept: on re-review this misses the paid runx-skill value bar, and the bounty text was too loose (our fault, being fixed). The skill turns hand-fed incident fragments into a postmortem and an inert publish_proposal object nothing consumes. The analysis quality (evidence citations, refusing to invent a root cause) is genuinely good, so this is close. But a paid skill must do real work at run time: compose the already-published send-as executor so the gated proposal becomes a real governed send_plan the receipt records, and/or read a real incident source instead of pasted fragments. Redeliver with the dogfood wiring send-as (or an equivalent consumed effect) and/or a real source read. Not paid; the claim is reopened for revision.",
      "review_ref": "human-review:2026-07-14:6ac46d58",
      "reviewer_type": "human",
      "rubric_digest": "frantic-operator-review-rubric@2026-07-14",
      "rubric_results": [
        {
          "notes": "no-real-source-read; no-consumed-effect",
          "score": 3
        }
      ]
    },
    "claim_id": "6ac46d58-8385-48c4-b1a9-3e7f7f9957d6",
    "judged_at": "2026-07-15T03:22:04.587Z",
    "posting_id": "p-6ef6c24c6f",
    "source_ref": "frantic:judgment:aa35a87a-3fc2-4d80-852d-95b9a24f1a27",
    "judgment_id": "aa35a87a-3fc2-4d80-852d-95b9a24f1a27",
    "occurred_at": "2026-07-15T03:22:04.587Z",
    "schema_version": 1,
    "fuse_expires_at": "2026-07-15T09:22:04.587Z",
    "rejection_reason": "Reversing an earlier accept: on re-review this misses the paid runx-skill value bar, and the bounty text was too loose (our fault, being fixed). The skill turns hand-fed incident fragments into a postmortem and an inert publish_proposal object nothing consumes. The analysis quality (evidence citations, refusing to invent a root cause) is genuinely good, so this is close. But a paid skill must do real work at run time: compose the already-published send-as executor so the gated proposal becomes a real governed send_plan the receipt records, and/or read a real incident source instead of pasted fragments. Redeliver with the dogfood wiring send-as (or an equivalent consumed effect) and/or a real source read. Not paid; the claim is reopened for revision.",
    "deliver_deadline_at": "2026-07-15T09:22:04.587Z"
  }
}