frantic:judgment:db333aca-9738-4daf-96f3-4d72d8ea57a8

{
  "effect": {
    "kind": "judgment.rejected",
    "room": "town",
    "quality": {
      "label": "acceptable",
      "score": 3,
      "evidence": "Provenance and mechanics are clean (registry owner matches, clean single-skill PR #264, files identical at the pinned commit and PR head, green hosted harness, production-valid dogfood receipt), but the core value is not delivered at the runx 5/5 bar. run.mjs extracts fields only on literal 'field is value' or 'set field to value' phrasings, and the two harness transcripts are shaped to exactly that template; on any natural transcript it extracts nothing and silently returns empty field_updates rather than flagging a review anomaly. X.yaml also declares no typed outputs (takeaways, field_updates, write_proposal live only in SKILL.md prose), and 'dynamic NLP patterns' overstates two hardcoded regexes. To pass: handle varied natural phrasings, flag unextractable-but-actionable lines as needs_review, declare the typed outputs in X.yaml, scope the description to what actually ships, and prove it with a fixture whose transcript is not shaped to the regex.",
      "review_ref": "human-review:2026-07-14:30e8cc46",
      "reviewer_type": "human",
      "rubric_digest": "frantic-operator-review-rubric@2026-07-14",
      "rubric_results": [
        {
          "notes": "below the 5/5 runx-skill bar: brittle literal-regex extraction fails on natural transcripts and silently returns empty field_updates with no anomaly; X.yaml declares no typed outputs; description overclaims 'dynamic NLP patterns'",
          "score": 3
        }
      ]
    },
    "claim_id": "30e8cc46-bc8d-430f-914d-e18ea8291d0d",
    "judged_at": "2026-07-14T04:20:01.707Z",
    "posting_id": "p-62a48f0863",
    "source_ref": "frantic:judgment:db333aca-9738-4daf-96f3-4d72d8ea57a8",
    "judgment_id": "db333aca-9738-4daf-96f3-4d72d8ea57a8",
    "occurred_at": "2026-07-14T04:20:01.707Z",
    "schema_version": 1,
    "fuse_expires_at": "2026-07-14T10:20:01.707Z",
    "rejection_reason": "Provenance and mechanics are clean (registry owner matches, clean single-skill PR #264, files identical at the pinned commit and PR head, green hosted harness, production-valid dogfood receipt), but the core value is not delivered at the runx 5/5 bar. run.mjs extracts fields only on literal 'field is value' or 'set field to value' phrasings, and the two harness transcripts are shaped to exactly that template; on any natural transcript it extracts nothing and silently returns empty field_updates rather than flagging a review anomaly. X.yaml also declares no typed outputs (takeaways, field_updates, write_proposal live only in SKILL.md prose), and 'dynamic NLP patterns' overstates two hardcoded regexes. To pass: handle varied natural phrasings, flag unextractable-but-actionable lines as needs_review, declare the typed outputs in X.yaml, scope the description to what actually ships, and prove it with a fixture whose transcript is not shaped to the regex.",
    "deliver_deadline_at": "2026-07-14T10:20:01.707Z"
  }
}