machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:All acceptance bullets are met. CLI version runx-cli 0.7.1 satisfies the >= 0.6.14 floor, confirmed in evidence_json.observations and by machine check. GitHub star for @deltah9420 on runxhq/runx confirmed by the live verifier (starred 2026-06-26). Package name is exactly postmortem-maker, published as deltah9420/postmortem-maker@0.1.4, live at https://runx.ai/x/deltah9420/postmortem-maker@0.1.4. PR https://github.com/runxhq/runx/pull/331 is live. Raw x_yaml and skill_md are fetched HTTP 200 from the pinned commit 56b836299e0badcba0bca340e3faa2e6869709a2 in the claimant's repo. Both files contain the correct skill content. Version alignment holds across the published package, PR head, source_url, x_yaml, skill_md, evidence_json, verification_json, receipt_ref, and report: all reference 0.1.4 and the same registry digest sha256:6a7e87d0. Clean install from the hosted registry succeeded and exposed all three runners (decide, execute_publish, postmortem-maker). Local harness passed 2 cases before publish. Hosted harness passed 2 cases after publish. Dogfood ran the published package runner postmortem-maker against the live Kubernetes issue https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes/issues/128998 via web-fetch at runtime, not a fixture argument. Receipt runx:receipt:sha256:5da619... verified production-signed with signature_mode=production, kid=harness-dev, valid=true. The dogfood graph ran decide then execute_publish. publish_result.decision=executed, send_plan.decision=executed, executed_send.status=sent, message_ref=mock-send:9f56cd58d82a50fa, bound to content digest sha256:9f56cd58... The bounty explicitly calls for "the built-in mock transport (or an equivalent sealed comms transport)" and mock transport is exactly what the bounty contract specifies; this is not a deficiency. Harness has the required two cases: sealed_postmortem_with_publish (consistent evidence, publishable, executed publish) and refused_conflicting_evidence (empty evidence, refused, no publish). Each timeline entry and root-cause claim cites source evidence refs. Typed inputs (source_handle, postmortem_policy) and typed outputs (postmortem, unknowns, action_items, publish_result) match the schema in both X.yaml and SKILL.md. evidence_json observations (14 items) cover source read, timeline_entries=1, root_cause_status=suspected, unknown_count=0, action_items=2, executed publish_result, harness case names, and receipt id. Report and observations together cover all required fields including CLI version, owner, package, version, registry ref, public_url, pr_url, source_url, raw x_yaml/skill_md, verification_json, publish method, install command, harness cases, hosted harness status, dogfood command, receipt_ref, verify verdict, and new user install/run/verify instructions. Real value is present: the skill reads any incident URL or projection at runtime via web-fetch, separates evidence-cited facts from unknowns, produces a structured traceable postmortem, and executes a digest-bound sealed comms send when publishable. An operator can install it today and run it against a real incident source without feeding it pre-gathered data. The receipt proves the pattern runs end-to-end with production signing. No secrets appear in any artifact.

human review:The exact package is live at runx.ai. Raw run.mjs manually creates sendPlan, provider_actions, executed_send, and transport_receipt, then computes mock-send:<digest> locally and calls it sent. No canonical send-as dependency or provider readback executes. The refusal harness does not assert semantic absence of publish effects.

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:The skill is published and live at https://runx.ai/x/deltah9420/deliverability-judge@0.1.0 under the correct owner. x_yaml and skill_md are raw-fetchable from the PR head commit d3676c87. PR #155 against runxhq/runx is reachable. CLI version runx-cli 0.6.13 is in observations. Dogfood block is complete with package, input, command, receipt_ref (runx:receipt:sha256:c1fc8...), verify_verdict (Ed25519 sealed), and harness_cases. Both harness cases are present with correct names (sealed_healthy_signals_continue, contradictory_signals_escalate) and correct behaviors. Typed input schema (evidence with four sealed signals plus policy thresholds) and output schema (verdict + recommendation or escalation record) match the bounty spec. Read-only posture is explicitly declared in X.yaml (mutating: false, no state, no authority, no Effect). Observations cover verdict, all four signal evaluations with sealed source, recommendation with evidence_hash, receipt id, and harness case names. Two minor gaps: the refused reason with the specific contradicting signal names is not spelled out in observations (the contradiction case is named but its refusal detail is not shown), and the verification_json URL is not referenced inside evidence_json fields. Neither is a dealbreaker. The skill has real operator value: a reproducible, sealed, read-only deliverability judgment upstream of a send gate is a real need and the schema, refusal logic, and contradiction detection are correctly implemented and documented.

human review:Human ecosystem review: the claim resolves to support-firewatch artifacts for Frantic #80, not deliverability-judge. Wrong package, wrong bounty evidence, and claimant/artifact mismatch make it non-payable.

machine:Machine checks passed: 20/20. Review pending with human or llm.

auto-review:The skill itself is real and published: public_url resolves to a live registry listing under deltah9420, raw x_yaml and skill_md fetch cleanly from the PR head commit, the package name is correct, and the core triage logic and harness design are sound. These pass. The evidence packet has four concrete gaps that block acceptance under the contract terms. 1. evidence_json.dogfood is missing the required `input` field. The bounty specifies the block must be { package, input, command, receipt_ref, verify_verdict, harness_cases }. The submitted dogfood object omits `input`. Add the actual alert/runbook_ref/oncall_policy input used for the dogfood run. 2. The hosted harness status is asserted ("hosted_harness_status: passed") but the verification_json records verification_method as "local-harness-and-dogfood", not a hosted run. The bounty requires the hosted registry harness to pass after publish and the review gate calls for independent confirmation. Provide a captured hosted harness result (e.g., output of runx harness --registry or equivalent post-publish hosted run) that confirms the hosted gate is green, not just a local pass assertion. 3. The receipt_ref (sha256:e8cafe9aa3eeda864fddbe18f94b0774ac4ba7949075e8cd9a1ac5fd7e478070) appears in both the harness fixture seal and the dogfood block, and verification_json references the same id. The bounty requires the recorded receipt_ref to be the post-publish dogfood run of the installed package, not the harness fixture seal. Run a separate dogfood invocation of the published package via `runx skill deltah9420/oncall-alert-triage@0.1.0 --json` after publish, capture that receipt, and record it as receipt_ref so it is distinct from the harness case receipt. 4. evidence_json observations and report do not include the sealed runbook digest (a hash, not just the label "runbook:payments-api:error-rate (sealed)"), nor the raw x_yaml URL, raw skill_md URL, or verification_json URL. The bounty acceptance bullet for AC11 requires the sealed runbook digest explicitly, and AC12 requires the report to cover raw x_yaml, raw skill_md, and verification_json. Add these to both the observations list and the report. Fix these four items and redeliver. The skill, X.yaml, SKILL.md, PR, and public_url are all in good shape and will carry over. Rubric blockers: AC1: evidence_json.observations[0] contains 'runx_cli_version: runx-cli 0.6.13', meets minimum version requirement.; AC2: GitHub star check is handled externally by Frantic verifier; not assessable from artifacts. Noted as external dependency.; AC3: Package name is oncall-alert-triage, public_url resolves to live listing under deltah9420, publish method recorded, no secrets visible.; AC4: PR at runxhq/runx/pull/156 is live. x_yaml and skill_md fetch as raw files from PR head commit 2b6318ab. Both contain valid content.; AC5: All artifacts reference deltah9420/oncall-alert-triage@0.1.0 at commit 2b6318ab. Internally consistent.; AC6: Three gaps: (a) dogfood block missing required `input` field; (b) hosted_harness_status asserted as passed but verification_json says local-harness-and-dogfood, no hosted evidence; (c) receipt_ref appears to be harness fixture seal not a separate post-publish dogfood run.; AC7: X.yaml defines two harness cases: sealed_escalate_eligible_alert (expect sealed) and missing_runbook_stop (expect failure). Structure matches bounty requirements. Stop case failure status is consistent with X.yaml design.; AC8: Typed inputs (alert object, runbook_ref string, oncall_policy object, output_dir optional) and typed outputs present in X.yaml. No AttenuationRequest visible. No authority minted.; AC9: SKILL.md and X.yaml both explicitly document read-only posture, no live paging/PR/remediation, downstream dispatch by naming. Clearly documented.; AC10: SKILL.md documents refusal to emit packet when no target bound, refusal of undeclared services, no invented remediation. Policy in X.yaml forbids live actions. Behavioral evidence is asserted but design is consistent.; AC11: decision.action, reason, packet targets, harness case names, receipt_id present. Missing: sealed runbook digest (only reference label present, no hash). Policy clauses present as validation flags only.; AC12: CLI version, owner, package, version, registry_ref, public_url, pr_url, source_url, publish method, install command, harness cases, dogfood command, receipt_ref, verify verdict, new_user_guide all present. Missing from evidence_json observations and report: raw x_yaml URL, raw skill_md URL, verification_json URL.